Skip to content

Survey latest results

We are conducting a POLL on the Seven Pillars of Reform for the Catholic Church. These ‘pillars’ are based on the booklet “Christ’s Idea of Authority in the Church”, by John Wijngaards.

In total 870 submission
WOMEN SHOULD BE ADMITTED TO ALL MINISTRIES / Auch Frauen sollten ordiniert werden / Las mujeres tambien deberian ser ordinadas.
Jesus’ words at the Last Supper “Do this in memory of me!” were also addressed to women. Tens of thousands of women served as sacramentally ordained deacons during the first millennium. Women’s exclusion from the priesthood and episcopacy can be shown to be due to cultural patriarchal prejudice. ('Christ’s Idea' Chs. 9 and 23)

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions
ON INSTITUTIONAL MATTERS, MINISTERS SHOULD BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE TO THEIR COMMUNITIES AND SECULAR LAW / In institutionellen Angelegenheiten sollten Pfarrer Rechenschaft ablegen / En asuntos institucionales, los pastores deben rendir cuentas.
With regard to spiritual authority, ministers are accountable to God in their own conscience, and also to higher ministerial levels to some extent. They are not subject to any form of democratic control. However, to support its spiritual mission the Church has established institutions: church buildings, parish headquarters, schools, clinics, whatever. Responsibilities of persons in charge create forms of institutional authority. This covers administration, organization, appointment of personnel, finance, maintenance and so on. Every leader with this kind of authority, whether ordained or not, is fully accountable for all his actions to the community and secular law ('Christ’s Idea' Chs. 16 and 20).

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions
PASTORAL COUNCILS SHOULD BE DELIBERATIVE / Pastoralraete sollten Entscheidungen treffen / Los consejos pastorales deben tomar decisiones.
Jesus stressed the importance of the community of believers. The Second Vatican Council prescribed pastoral councils to be established on all levels ('Christus Dominus' §27). However, present Church Law states that such councils play only a consultative role. That means that the laity cannot take any decisions that bishops or priests need to follow. ('Christ’s Idea' Ch. 12)

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions
CHURCH LEADERS SHOULD LISTEN TO THE SPIRIT SPEAKING IN THE COMMUNITY / Kirchenfuehrer sollten auf den Heiligen Geist hoeren, der in der Gemeinschaft spricht / Los lideres de la iglesia deben escuchar al Espiritu que habla en la comunidad.
The Holy Spirit indicates what Christ wants for our time by speaking through the ‘sense of faith’ ('Christ’s Idea' Ch. 13), through scholars ('Christ’s Idea' Ch. 10) and through ‘prophets’ ('Christ’s Idea' Ch. 11). “God placed in the community first of all apostles, secondly prophets, thirdly teachers…” (1 Corinthians 12,28).

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions
‘CHURCH LAW' SHOULD RESPECT THE 'LIBERATION FROM WHICH CHRIST BROUGHT / Das Kirchenrecht sollte die 'Befreiung vom Gesetz' respektieren, die Christus gebracht hat / La 'Ley de la Iglesia' debe respetar la 'liberacion de la ley' que Cristo trajo
Christ taught us to live by love and for love. This brings freedom from any written law, also church law. “For freedom Christ has truly set us free. Now make sure that you stay free, and don’t get tied up again in slavery to law … If you are led by the Spirit, you are not under any law.” (Galatians 5,1.18) “In Christ Jesus the law of the Spirit of life has set you free from the law of sin and death.” (Romans 8,2). Love is the overriding command. (Christ’s Idea Ch. 8)

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions
If needed, each member of the community can exercise all sacramental functions.
Though Jesus gave special powers to the Apostles and their successors, he did not, on principle, restrict the inherent powers of all the faithful. Every baptised person can administer baptism and the sacrament of marriage. And, in the absence of ordained ministers, he or she can hear confessions, preside at the Eucharist and anoint the sick (Christ’s Idea Ch. 14).

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions
THE CHURCH SHOULD ALLOW REGIONAL VARIATION IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF REFORMS / Dei Kirche sollte regionale Unterschiede bei der Umsetzung von Reformen zulassen / La Iglesia debe permitir variacion regional en la implementacion de reformas.
During his public ministry Jesus adapted his actions and his preaching to the specific audience he was dealing with. Conditions vary widely between countries spanning the world across five continents. While universal principles should be laid down for the whole Church, bishops conferences should be allowed to oversee the gradual implementation of reforms in their own areas ('Christ’s Idea' Ch. 26).

Do you agree? Einverstanden? De acuerdo?

870 submissions

These views expressed by Catholics, are precious. They reveal ‘the sense of faith’ living in the consciousness of the People of God. And this ‘sense of faith’ – as the Second Vatican Council declared (Lumen Gentium, par 12) – are the source of the Church’s inerrancy.

If you have as yet not taken the Survey yourself, please do so now. You can do so from here: https://www.churchauthority.org/questionnaire/ .

Please, share this link also with your contacts and friends.

—*—